The Horan on the Name Tag

For more than twenty years, I looked for a man who had disappeared. His name was James Wallace Horan I. He was my grandfather, and I never knew him. Neither, really, did my Dad nor did he care to after this incident. He said didn’t care what I found but I suspect he would have.

James Wallace Horan I left my grandmother and their family when my father was only three years old. Dad never saw his biological father again. He grew up knowing almost nothing about him or the Horan family he came from.

When I started researching our family history at thirteen, finding this missing grandfather became my first great genealogical mystery. I wrote letters to Chicago and Cook County. I waited weeks for replies. I searched with the tiny handful of information available to me.

And I asked my grandmother.

She wasn't talking.

So I kept searching. Years passed, and then decades. My dad died without ever knowing that I would eventually find his father.

When the answer finally came, it arrived in a way so ridiculously improbable that, had Dad been there, I'm quite certain it would have become one of his favorite family stories.

A College Reunion

It was around 2009 when my cousin attended his college reunion. There is nothing particularly remarkable about that. At some point during the reunion, however, he was sitting on a bench with his name tag showing Horan.

Now, Horan isn't exactly Smith or Jones in the United States. It's uncommon enough that when you encounter another Horan, you notice. This stranger noticed. So she walked over and introduced herself saying “My maiden name is Horan”. They started talking and, as Horans apparently do when encountering one another in the wild, they started comparing notes. Somewhere in that conversation, two strangers at a college reunion realized something extraordinary:

Their grandfathers were the same man.

I had spent more than twenty years actively searching for James Wallace Horan I. My cousin found his family because he happened to walk past a woman sitting on a bench wearing a name tag.

Genealogy has a sense of humor.

The Phone Call

My cousin called me afterward and told me the whole fantastic story: the reunion, the woman approaching him at the bench, the Horan name tag and the conversation that followed. The sheer improbability of the whole thing was almost impossible to believe.

And then came the part I had been waiting most of my life to hear.

He had found our grandfather's family. The woman he met wasn't some distant Horan cousin connected to us six generations back. She was our fathers' niece. Her father was our fathers' half-brother. Suddenly, the man who had existed in my research primarily as a name wasn't quite so invisible anymore. There were people connected to him. There was another family. And there was a history none of us had known.

But there was another surprise waiting for us.

Chicago Wasn't the Beginning

For most of my life, I had known one central fact about my grandfather: he had abandoned my grandmother and their family in Chicago. That was the mystery I had been trying to solve. Where did he go? Why did he leave? What happened to him afterward?

Except now I discovered I had been asking the wrong question. Because my father's family wasn't the first family James Wallace Horan I had left.

Before Chicago, there had been St. Louis. He had a family there, and he deserted them. Then he went to Chicago, where he eventually had another family.

Ours. And he deserted them, too.

The missing grandfather I had been searching for since I was thirteen hadn't simply disappeared from my father's life. He had done it before.

Finding an Answer and Finding More Questions

There's a peculiar thing that happens in genealogy when you finally solve a mystery you've carried for years. You imagine an answer will bring closure. Instead, it usually brings twelve new questions. Finding my grandfather was like that. For decades, James Wallace Horan I had been an empty space in our family history. My dad couldn't tell me about his father's family because he simply didn't know them. My grandmother refused to talk about him. Every trail I followed seemed to disappear.

Then, through an almost impossible coincidence at a college reunion, suddenly there was a whole other branch of the family. People who had been there all along. People we didn't know existed. And people who, as it turned out, were connected to the very same man whose disappearance had started me on this journey when I was thirteen years old.

There is a sadness in that discovery that I can't ignore. My dad never knew.

He never got the phone call I did. He never got to hear that somewhere out there was a half-brother he hadn't known about. He never got to compare the stories he had been told with what we eventually discovered. For a man who loved family stories as much as Dad did, I wish more than anything that I could have told him this one. I can imagine his reaction: the questions, the disbelief, and eventually, because he was James, probably the laughter at the sheer absurdity of how it happened. More than twenty years of searching. Letters, records, dead ends and waiting. And in the end?

A college reunion. A woman notices a name tag with one little word printed on a name tag: Horan.

Sometimes genealogy is research. Sometimes it's persistence. And every once in a very great while, your family's missing history is sitting on a bench, waiting for someone to notice the name.

Previous
Previous

The Family Before Ours

Next
Next

Where It All Began