Where It All Began

I blame my dad.

Or perhaps I should give him credit.

Either way, this all started with James.

My dad loved to tell stories. Stories about our family. Stories about Ireland. Stories that were hilarious or absurd, stories that were serious, and stories that somehow managed to become more entertaining every time he told them. And Dad didn't require a special occasion. A Sunday drive was a perfectly good time for a family story. So was the dinner table. Apparently, so was a commercial break during a Chicago Bears game.

If there was an opportunity to tell a story, Dad could find it.

And I listened.

We Are Descended from Brian Boru

One of the earliest family stories I remember was a rather spectacular one. According to my father, we were descended from Brian Boru, High King of Ireland.

Not possibly descended from him.

Not there's an old family story that maybe...

No.

We were descended from Brian Boru. Dad told me all about him: who he was, why he was important, how he became High King, the battles he fought. I learned the story of this legendary Irish king because, according to my father, this wasn't simply Irish history.

This was our history.

When you're a kid and your father tells you that you are descended from a High King of Ireland, you don't necessarily stop to ask for his sources. You listen. And somewhere along the way, I began to wonder.

Was it true?

That question would become a rather important one in my life.

But There Was Another Story

For all the stories my father knew about Ireland and our family, there was one enormous blank space in his own history.

His father.

My dad's biological father left the family when Dad was only three years old. He never saw him again.

His name was James Wallace Horan I, the man my father had been named after. And that was about all I had. To my thirteen-year-old mind, this was an irresistible mystery. How could your father simply disappear from your life when you were three years old?

Where did he go?

Why did he leave?

What happened to him?

What was he like?

Did he have another family?

Was he still alive?

And perhaps most tantalizing of all: Who were the Horans who came before him?

My dad couldn't answer those questions. He didn't know his father's family. His father had disappeared so early in his life that an entire half of his family history had essentially disappeared with him. So I turned to the person I thought surely must have the answers.

My grandmother.

Grandma Wasn't Talking

I called Dad's mother and started asking questions about her former husband. She wanted absolutely nothing to do with that conversation.

Not a little reluctant.

Not vague.

She simply would not talk about him. At all.

Whatever had happened between my grandparents belonged to a part of her life she had no intention of reopening for an inquisitive thirteen-year-old granddaughter armed with questions. And she never changed her mind. She carried whatever she knew about James Wallace Horan I with her until the day she died.

Of course, telling a thirteen-year-old who is already fascinated by a mystery that nobody is going to tell her the answer is not necessarily an effective way of making the mystery go away. At least it wasn't with this thirteen-year-old. If no one could tell me what had happened to him, I was going to find him myself.

Genealogy Before Google

This was around 1984. There was no Ancestry. No FamilySearch search box. No digitized newspaper archive waiting for me at two in the morning. No typing a name into Google and disappearing down a rabbit hole for six hours. My first attempt at genealogical research involved paper, envelopes, stamps, and an extraordinary amount of patience.

I began writing letters to Chicago and Cook County looking for information about a man named James Horan.

Then I waited.

And waited.

Weeks could pass before an answer arrived. Sometimes, after all that waiting, the answer essentially amounted to: There are too many. You'll need to narrow it down. There was only one problem. I didn't have anything to narrow it down with. The man I was searching for had vanished from my father's life when Dad was three. My father didn't know his father's family. My grandmother wasn't talking.

I had a name.

A city.

A mystery.

And very little else.

So I kept looking.

Forty-Two Years Later...

I couldn't have known it then, but those first letters were the beginning of something that would stay with me for the rest of my life. I was thirteen years old when I started looking for James Wallace Horan I. I'm fifty-five now.

For 42 years, I have been following names through records, tracing families across cities, states and countries, collecting photographs and documents, asking questions, testing family stories, finding new mysteries and occasionally solving very old ones.

The Horan line, Ó hOdhráin, remains at the heart of my research, but inevitably one family became many. O'Neill. Wallace. Byrne. McGarvey. McClellan. Whynot. And more branches than thirteen-year-old me could possibly have imagined.

But when I think about where all of this began, I don't picture a family tree. I picture my dad. I can hear James telling another story at the dinner table or during a Sunday drive. I can imagine a Bears game going to commercial and Dad deciding that these next thirty seconds were an excellent opportunity to explain something about Ireland. And somewhere in there is a thirteen-year-old girl listening to him and beginning to ask questions.

Is that really what happened?

Where did these people come from?

Who were they?

And, most importantly:

Can I find out?

Forty-two years later, I'm still trying.

As for whether Dad was right about Brian Boru?

Well...

That's a story for another day.

Previous
Previous

The Horan on the Name Tag