When I finally discovered my grandfather's first family in St. Louis, I thought I might finally begin getting some answers. And I did, although not quite the answers I had expected.
For most of my life, I had believed the story of James Wallace Horan I began with my grandmother and father in Chicago. I knew he had left when Dad was only three years old, and I had spent decades wondering where he went and what became of him. What I hadn't known was that Chicago wasn't the beginning of the story at all. Before my grandmother, before my father, and before the family I had spent so many years trying to trace, there had been another family. And they had been looking for him, too.
Before Chicago, There Was St. Louis
James Wallace Horan I was born in St. Louis, Missouri, in 1909, the son of James Thomas Horan and Mae Helen (Wallace) Horan. St. Louis wasn't simply a place he had passed through on his way to Chicago. It was his birthplace, the home of his parents, and the place where he began his own family. His first wife was Marie, and together they had a son named Gilbert.
At some point, James left Marie and Gilbert behind and made his way to Chicago, where he would eventually marry my grandmother and become the father of my dad, James. And then, as he had done in St. Louis, he left that family, too. For years, I had thought I was trying to solve one disappearance. As it turned out, there had been two.
What makes the story even more curious is that the two families apparently didn't know the same things about one another. From what I've been able to learn, Marie knew about the family James had established in Chicago. Whether she remained in contact with his parents or any other members of the Horan family, I don't know. But in Chicago, my grandmother and father knew nothing about the family James had left behind in St. Louis. Two families connected by the same man, living separate lives, with one knowing something of the other's existence while the other remained completely unaware.
As I began piecing together the St. Louis family, I discovered just how small that branch had become. James and Marie had one child, Gilbert. Gilbert, in turn, had one child, a daughter named Carolyn. She was the woman whose Horan name tag had caught my cousin's attention at that extraordinary college reunion around 2009. A chance conversation between two people who happened to share an uncommon surname had reunited branches of a family that hadn't even known one another existed.
After more than twenty years of searching, the breakthrough had come from a woman sitting on a bench wearing a name tag. I still find that ridiculous in the most wonderful way. But Carolyn brought more than a new branch to add to my family tree. She brought information about a grandfather I had spent most of my life trying to find, and she brought a story about her own father, Gilbert, that I hadn't expected.
Another Son, Another Search
One of the most remarkable things I learned was that I hadn't been the only person searching for James Wallace Horan I. Gilbert had been looking for his father, too. At some point, he had asked a friend who was a congressman to help locate the man who had disappeared from his family. That request eventually produced a report, and in 1965, Gilbert received the results.
His father had been found, but there was a terrible catch. James Wallace Horan I had died six years earlier, in Duarte, California, in 1959, at approximately fifty years old.
I can only imagine what it must have been like for Gilbert to finally receive information about his father, only to discover that any possibility of seeing him again had already passed. And there was my own dad, who had lost contact with his father at three years old and never saw him again. Two sons, born into different families, both separated from the same father and both growing up without knowing the full story of the man who had left them behind.
Decades later, Gilbert's daughter Carolyn would share that report with me, connecting his search with the one I had begun when I was thirteen. I had spent so many years thinking of James Wallace Horan I as my missing grandfather that I hadn't considered there might be other people carrying their own questions about him.
The Trail Ends in California
The report Carolyn shared revealed that my grandfather's life had eventually taken him all the way to California. By the time of his death, James Wallace had married again. I haven't discovered any children from that marriage, although that doesn't necessarily mean there weren't any. His final years remain something of a mystery to me, and the circumstances surrounding his death raise even more questions.
According to the information in the report, James Wallace died following a massive abdominal and intestinal hemorrhage. Mercury was also found in his blood. How the mercury entered his system, whether it was connected to the hemorrhage, and what circumstances surrounded his death are questions I cannot answer from the information I have. And I'm not sure I ever will.
It's a strange thing to spend so much of your life searching for someone, only to discover that finding him doesn't necessarily mean understanding him. I know where James Wallace Horan I was born. I know who his parents were, and I know about the families he left behind. I know that his life eventually ended in California, far from St. Louis and Chicago. But I don't know why he made the choices he did. I don't know what he was searching for, what he regretted, or whether he ever thought about the children who grew up without him.
There are other questions, too. His parents, James Thomas and Mae Helen Horan, both died in 1932. His sister had died in 1919, and his grandparents in 1917 and 1926. What did they know about his life? Did they know about Marie and Gilbert? Did they know about his second family in Chicago? Were there conversations, letters, or family disagreements that might have explained something about what happened?
I don't know. The records can tell me when these people were born and when they died. Sometimes they can tell me where they lived, what they did for a living, or whom they married. But they can't always tell me what people knew, what they kept to themselves, or what happened behind closed doors. And after more than forty years of genealogy, I've learned that some questions simply don't come with answers.
The Brother Dad Never Knew
Of all the things I've discovered in more than forty years of researching my family, this may be the one that hurts the most. My dad never knew he had a half-brother. His name was Gilbert, and he was out there all along.
My father was a man who absolutely loved family stories. He delighted in telling them, whether they were hilarious, improbable, serious, or some combination of all three. He could turn a Sunday drive, the dinner table, or a commercial break during a Chicago Bears game into an opportunity to tell us something about Ireland or the Horans. He could spend hours talking about ancestors he'd never met and places he'd never been. And yet, he went through his entire life without knowing he had a brother. Not some distant cousin buried in a forgotten branch of the family tree, but a brother.
That is crushing to me, because I think Dad would have loved to know. I would have loved to tell him and to see his face when he learned that somewhere out there was another son of James Wallace Horan I, someone who might have understood something about growing up with a father who disappeared.
Would they have gotten along? Would they have recognized something of themselves in one another? Would they have shared stories about the father neither really knew? Would Dad have told Gilbert about Brian Boru and our supposed descent from the High King of Ireland? Knowing Dad, I suspect he would have found a way to work that story into the conversation. I wish I could have been there to hear it.
But I can't know what might have happened between them, and that's what makes this discovery so difficult. For years, I thought the great mystery was finding my grandfather. I wanted to know where he went, what became of him, and why he had left my father behind. Looking back, though, the discovery that means the most to me isn't really about James Wallace Horan I at all. It's about Gilbert, Carolyn, and the family we didn't know we had. And it's about my dad, who would have loved to know that somewhere out there, beyond all the stories he told about the Horans, there was a brother whose story he had never heard.
I can't give Dad that discovery now. I can't make that phone call or sit across the table and tell him what I've found. But I can tell the story. I can put their names together, preserve the records, and make sure that the generations who come after us know that these two families were always connected, even when they didn't know it themselves.
Maybe that's part of why I've spent so much of my life doing this. Because sometimes family history isn't just about discovering the people who came before us. Sometimes it's about remembering the connections they never had the chance to make.
And Dad, if I could tell you just one more family story, I think this would be the one.